Do cats really hate petting?

Do cats really hate petting?

You may have caught wind of a recent study from Ramos et al., “Are cats (Felis catus) from multi-cat households more stressed? Evidence from assessment of fecal glucocorticoid metabolite analysis”, which was just published in the journal Physiology & Behavior.

Here’s just a taste of the headlines of news stories that covered the study:

docatshatepetting3

If you’re a cat lover like me, you might be feeling a little concerned! Let’s look at what the study sought to examine, what they found and what they didn’t find, and how the media interpreted the results.

The authors state that their main research question was to determine if living in a multi-cat household is stressful for cats. Cats are considered somewhat flexible in their ability to co-habitate with other cats, although this can depend on availability of resources. Feral cats will congregate over food sources and aid in co-mothering, and of course, many of our pet cats live in groups, as many cat owners have more than one—the average number of cats per cat-owning household is 2.1. But group living may cause stress when animals must compete for access to resources.

Previous studies looking at stress levels in co-housed cats only looked at large group sizes, so the authors of the current study looked at more “typical” household cat population sizes: solo cats, cats living in pairs, and cats living in groups of three to four. The study included 60 households (23 singletons; 20 households with 2 cats; 17 households with 3–4 cats) for a total of 120 cats. Cats were divided into two age groups (under 2 years/over 2 years). All cats were at least six months of age, indoors only, and lived in houses with no dogs. None of the cats were subject to any stressors during the study such as vet visits and no cats had reported behavior problems. Unaltered cats were included in the study unless they were in heat.

docatshatepetting2Four fecal samples were collected and frozen for each cat by the owner, just after elimination; they were then assayed for glucocorticoid metabolites (GCM; stress hormones).  The owners were asked to describe their cats as either bossy, timid or easygoing, and answered some questions about interactions with their cat (including petting).

The results indicated no effect of group size, sex, or neuter status on GCM. However, there was an interaction between age and group size, with younger cats having higher GCM if they were singly housed compared to if living in homes with 3–4 cats. For cats over 2 years of age the effect was the opposite—living with in groups of 3 or 4 cats increased presence of stress hormones in feces. There were no differences in GCM levels based on age when cats lived in pairs.

What does this have to do with petting and stress? Good question. Owners were asked if cats appreciated being petted, and owners could select: “enjoy”, “tolerate” or “dislike.”  Note: no cats were pet during the study, nor were owners asked how much they actually try to pet their cats.

There was a statistically non-significant indication that cats who “tolerate” petting had higher GCM than those who “dislike” petting. Now I’m going to tell you why I think this is a weak (or possibly non-interesting) finding.

First, are glucocorticoids a good indicator of stress? The problem with using GCMs as a measure of stress is that stress hormones can fluctuate in response to many different things—such as time of day, food, excitement, and most animals have different baseline levels of these hormones. Without other controls, basically what you can say is that at the time of defecation, some cats may have had higher GCMs than others.

There are some statistical issues with how the data were analyzed in this study, and how the results were reported. As the paper stated, for the petting variable “there was some evidence of a potential main effect.” That means that there was not enough statistical evidence that there was a true difference between cats who enjoy, tolerate or dislike petting, although there may have been a trend in that direction. Another concern is that the effect size was not reported—so even though it’s a questionable finding, and likely not statistically significant, if there is a difference between the different groups of cats, how “big” of a difference is there between cats who “tolerate” versus “dislike” petting?

Finally, the authors found a kind of weird result. Basically, cats who only “tolerate” petting had a higher GCM than cats who “dislike” petting, but not higher than cats who “enjoy” petting. This is again, based on owner report. How well do owners distinguish between cats who dislike or only tolerate petting? What were the criteria for categorizing these cats? Why would cats who “dislike” petting have low stress levels on par with cats who do enjoy it?

Then there is the weird explanation for the weird result: “It may be that those who overtly dislike the activity are avoided or manage to avoid it, unlike those who tolerate it.” Maybe, but that’s not the data that was actually collected, so the explanation seems a bit strange as a possible hypothesis. Were the owners even petting their cats when they collected the stress hormone samples? (I doubt many people pet their cats while they are defecating!)—so how could petting contribute to stress unless you know how much the owners actually pet their cats? Also, only four cats were reported as disliking petting, so the sample size is also problematic.

docatshatepetting1Sadly, and not surprisingly, this kind of strange result is the part of the study that the media ran wild with. Suddenly, cats hate petting, even if they seem to tolerate it, and you are stressing your cat out! What is probably most useful is learning to read cats’ behavioral signals, and let them tell you if they like petting.

At the same time, the media ignored the significant finding about age and group living, one that could lead to interesting future studies, especially with better measures of stress. Do younger cats cope better with living in large groups? Are they bored if they live alone? As they age, do they become stressed out with living with other cats or is this due to being introduced to other cats as adults? Based on GCM measures, the results suggest that for cats over the age of two, living alone or with one feline buddy is just fine, but no more please; and when you are young, the more the merrier! I hope to see more research on this important topic in the future!

So a potentially interesting cat study leaves me wanting a bit more. But really, the frustrating part is how the media responded! Instead of increasing our understanding of cats and their behavior, the representation of the results of this study could just reinforce the idea that cats are not affectionate, something we cat experts know just isn’t true.

 

Images by Jacqueline Munera.

Share this post:

Leave a Reply

*

6 comments

  1. Pingback: Do cats really hate petting? | cats and squirrels and other important things...

  2. Julie

    Love this cat talk! This conversation makes me think of YouTube videos of cats who may not like the petting (or holding) they are receiving (and whether the humans in the videos are aware of this is another question). My question is: Do you think it is possible to examine whether petting is a stressful event, whether acute or chronic, for cats living in the home? And if investigated, do you think we might find that some of the headlines you listed above hold water?

  3. Mikel Delgado

    Julie,
    Great questions! I definitely think there are ways to measure cats’ responses to petting, and body language might be one really good way. I think of the funding Lincoln University just received to study feline facial expressions, so the findings could be very useful for looking at how cats respond to interactions with humans. I think that lots of cats love petting when it’s done properly, and they may be sensitive to many factors, such as their relationship with the petting human, scents (smokers or heavy perfume wearers might induce stress), where they are being petted and how well the human can read signals indicating that the cat has had enough…so in other words, I don’t think you can study how cats respond to petting without also studying the humans petting them!

  4. george

    my wife and I have one dog, male golden retriever, and two cats, brother and sister. our dog is almost 15 years old and our cats are 13. we adopted the cats from their litter about 8 weeks old. we adopted our dog when he was three years old and when we already had the cats for about one year. they have all always gotten along with each other.

    all of them, dog and cats, like to be petted. obviously, our dog enjoys being petted for longer periods of time and as often as we choose. however, both of our cats enjoy being petted for limited periods of time. the male cat has developed a regimen where he “signals” he wants to be petted by walking into one of our rooms and lying down to wait for me to pet him. the female cat frequently jumps onto our laps to take a nap and then we can pet her for as long as we want. also, the male cat, always sleeps with us at night, mostly curling up between my ankles.

    I realize mine is not a scientific study, but I believe my cats like to be petted and very much like to be around us and on top of us.

  5. Mikel Delgado

    George, I think your comment points out the importance of individual differences and learning to read your cat’s body language! Thanks for reading.

Type to Search

See all results